• 1998-99 – Simon Heald, Westside FC
  • 1999-00 – Iain Sneddon, Metro-Ford Wolves
  • 2000-01 – Danny Sankar, Indo FC
  • 2001-02 – Craig Chiasson, Rino’s Westside
  • 2002-03 – Shawn Blakeway, Surrey United
  • 2003-04 – Alex Elliott, Columbus FC and Peter Bergholz, SportsTown Firemen
  • 2004-05 – Joe Scigliano, Columbus-Clan FC
  • 2005-06 – Shawn Blakeway, Surrey United and Ryan Dormer, Sporting Club
  • 2006-07 – Niall Thompson, Firefighters
  • 2007-08 – Kevin Crouch, ICSF Inter
  • 2008-09 – Tiernan King, Columbus-Clan FC
  • 2009-10 – Tino Cucca, ICSF Inter
  • 2010-11 -
  • 2011-12 -
  • 2012-13 -